This week on Inland Journal, identity theft has grown increasingly sophisticated, targeting people of every age.
It can be devastating to the victims and their families, both financially and emotionally. Checking your credit report and regularly changing passwords are a starting point, but they're not adequate means of keeping ourselves safe. Not even staying offline altogether will protect us from these savvy and unscrupulous criminal networks.
After my family, as well as a close family member, were targeted by identity thieves, I wanted to know what can and should we do. I reached out to Detective Tim Schwering with the Spokane Police Department's Criminal Intelligence Unit. I asked him what forms can identity theft take, and what do we need to do to protect ourselves and our loved ones? The answers were even more concerning than I had anticipated.
The following interview has been edited for length and clarity.
KW: ID theft is such a pervasive issue in our society right now. What are the most frequent scams that you get calls on currently?
TS: A lot of the scams are focused on certainly identity theft, where someone gets their identity stolen from any number of the breaches that occur, whether it's American Express, whether it's your local utility company. Wherever your information gets out there, it gets sold on the dark web. You'll see a lot of crimes associated with identity theft.
You'll also see a lot of crimes, and we're really focused on this over the past couple of years, dealing with cryptocurrency scams, and specifically cryptocurrency ATM machines. That has been a very, very common scam, and those have been catastrophic to victims because their entire life savings gets wiped out in a very short amount of time. That money, in essence, is put in cryptocurrency and moved overseas, and there's no way to get the money back because they all go to countries that have no diplomatic relationships with the United States, so you can't serve federal or state warrants.
The money is just gone. We've had so many instances of that that have been going on for the last few years. That has been our primary focus.
KW: How does that work with cryptocurrency scams, where people are getting access to that? Are they doing it directly through the person who owns the crypto account, or are they going roundabout and getting their information to do it themselves?
TS: That is a good question. So what happens is you have these people on, think of any type of social media, any type, LinkedIn, of all things—I didn't know people still use that—but really anything that communicates with anyone else on the internet.
And so what will happen is, and you'll see this especially maybe on dating sites with maybe older people, and so they will meet somebody online, whether it's on a dating site, whether it's on Facebook, Words with Friends, and they will develop a relationship over time. And over time means several weeks, several months. I've had cases where the scam has gone on for several years.
Those types of scams are called "pig butchering". Pig butchering is actually derived from Chinese organized crime, where it is basically fattening up the pig to butcher it. And that's how they're viewing these victims.
And so what will happen is—and they can take a number of twists and turns—but a lot of times what will happen is a relationship gets developed. The victim thinks she or he is in love with the other person, and they've never met in person, of course, it's always online. And there will be something that will come up. It can be something as simple as, "Hey, I was traveling over to Paris."
I can think of one of my cases was that this victim was told that his girlfriend had lost her wallet, purse, everything, and needed money to get back home, and said, "Can you put $15,000 in a Bitcoin ATM machine?" And so that's the easiest way to get it to me. And so the victim did that because, again, he thought he was in a relationship with this woman, and that relationship had gone on, actually, for several months.
And so the money was sent through that Bitcoin ATM machine, and then once it was sent, that person disappeared. The number that had previously worked no longer worked. The profile on the original dating site where they had met was no longer there. Any form of communication they had, it was just off in the wind. And I can remember that was one of my first cases, and that was a case that you could trace that back to exchanges back in Southeast Asia, mainland China, and you'll have a lot of these scams are run by Chinese organized crime. That is in essence how that can start, but these are happening so frequently, they were coming in daily.
So the problem becomes where you have maybe they're the scams of old of the gift cards, where someone, you know, scratches the gift card off, takes pictures of it, and sends it to the scammer. That is certainly annoying to be out a few hundred dollars, maybe a thousand dollars, but it's not catastrophic like these other types of scams involving cryptocurrency ATMs, in that we've had cases of people throwing 50, 100, half a million dollars, record was over a million dollars in these machines, and they were going overseas. And again, there's no way to get that money back. And believe me, I tried.
I even reached out to the Hong Kong Police Department in a—in hindsight—naive effort to get that money back, and they told me kind of what you would expect they would tell me, and so that didn't really go anywhere. And so then we kind of downshifted and focused on prevention. And so started doing a lot of presentations around certainly Spokane City and Spokane County. And then started working on really looking at the ATMs themselves. Because kind of the theory was, at least my impression of dealing with cryptocurrency, is if you are savvy enough to be able to have a Coinbase or whatever app on your phone, and you're savvy enough to be able to link your accounts and buy and trade cryptocurrency, it seems highly unlikely that that same person would then go drive down to their local gas station and pay a 20% fee to move money into Bitcoin.
It just didn't make sense. On top of the fact that most of those were in fact scams, so you had a lot of people that were just throwing money into these things and just losing their entire life savings. So beginning to work with the Spokane City Council, because actually one of the poor council members had actually sat through three of my presentations, because he'd gone to like council meetings and obviously had gone to neighborhood council meetings, and I think more just in an attempt so he didn't have to listen to me anymore, give any more presentations, he said, "Well, why don't we just why don't we just ban these things?" And so yes, that's a great idea.
In the meantime, I was also working with the state Department of Financial Institutions to try to get at least regulation happening at the state level. We've tried that now for two years, we're going to get another run at it here. We haven't gotten any traction with that. So then we downshifted again focusing at the local level where the council—and again I'd briefed the council on this at their own session, and also at the neighborhood council meetings, and so they were very well aware of what was going on.
Spokane was one of the, certainly the first in Washington state that just banned them outright. And so then the process was going through and working with other businesses that had them saying, hey you can't have these anymore, you got to get rid of them. And then letting DFI know that no new ATMs can be registered.
KW: And DFI is?
TS: Sorry, the Department of Financial Institutions. I have, I did presentations with Airway Heights City Council. They passed a ban. The Spokane County Commissioners, they just enacted a ban about two or three weeks ago.
And so we were at a high of, I think, about 85 cryptocurrency ATM machines here in Spokane County, and now we're down to six. And so the hope is we can get rid of those here pretty soon. Even worked with Kennewick, and Kennewick has since instituted a ban as well.
So there's a lot more work to do, and I've been partnering with AARP who've been very, very helpful in kind of getting the messaging out and making people aware of it. Because again, it is, it was so pervasive, and it was just happening to so many people, especially older people. I mean it was happening to everybody, but a lot of the elderly folks, because again I think people were lonely, and they're trying to meet people, and so you're already putting yourself out there to begin with. It was just kind of right for fraud.
KW: Some people are going to hear these stories and say, I would never fall for that. Well and good. But that doesn't mean that your identity can't still be stolen. So what are the best steps to take to prevent that in the first place?
TS: Absolutely. So one of the first things you can do is simply put a freeze on your credit, and you can go to the three credit bureaus. It's TransUnion, Equifax, and Experian are the three major credit bureaus.
And what you do is you just go on their website. It's a free service, but you want to freeze your credit at each one, not just one of them. And what that does is it basically puts a lock on your credit, where you can't get new credit, whether it's a credit card, car loan, mortgage, without that credit freeze being lifted.
Again, when you want to buy that new house, when you buy a new car, you just call those three credit bureaus, say you need your freeze lifted. They will lift it, and then you can get the loan or whatever it is that you need, and then reinstitute that freeze. But then what that does do is if someone does get a hold of your identity, they can't go out new lines of credit, opening utility services, any number of things that can happen.
And people should know that, and I've had this asked of me during presentations: "Tim, I'm not really on the internet. I don't do very much online, so I feel like I'm pretty safe." The problem becomes is that every company you work with is online.
So American Express, your medical provider, really anybody out there has had some sort of breach at some point or another. Or you've received that in the mail, where, hey, you've been a victim of a breach, here are your rights. That information gets out there, and it's on the dark web. So what I tell people is even if you've never touched a computer or a cell phone, is just assume that your identity's out there on the dark web being sold, because I think everybody's is at this point.
KW: That's daunting to think about. Is it enough to freeze your credit on one of the credit bureaus?
TS: I would recommend doing all three, because the issue becomes is that certain companies might go to a specific credit bureau to run your credit. So you want to hit all three of them, and that will keep you as safe as possible, as opposed to just doing one or two of them.
KW: And you said having them locked or frozen is a free service.
TS: It's a free service that each company provides.
KW: So let's say someone has had their identity stolen—what we think of is now the more traditional way, but via the internet, via your information that's online—what do you do next?
TS: So the first thing to do is, and again, sometimes it'll be a case of, are you aware of it? Is it something that you participated in, maybe with the scams that we're talking about before? But start talking to your people that you trust, that you know. That's kind of the first thing of like, hey, what direction should I go here? The second thing is to reach out, make a police report, so that way it's at least documented, you get that police report.
Is it going to be investigated necessarily? Not necessarily, but that certainly can happen. But that's important then to show the other companies and whomever that you might need to talk to is that, yes, you were a victim of identity theft. Here is my incident report number.
And then you kind of move forward from there. You call your credit bureaus, making sure if you don't have that freeze on there, get that on there. Then get a copy of your credit report and see if there's any other types of new credit that you don't recognize and get that shut down.
That's going to be the cleanest way to get the initial triaging done of, all right, how bad is the damage? And then reach out to your own companies that you deal with on a daily basis, be it your banks, let them know. Maybe your bank wasn't hacked or maybe your account wasn't hacked, but they should know that anyway. And maybe out of an abundance of caution, they change your account number, they can do other things that would mitigate any further issues.
Those are kind of the first steps that one would take if they are the victim.
KW: And again, how important is having that police report to back you up with the companies that you're talking to? Do your credit card companies, if there is something fraudulent that happens, do they require that police report as part of their documentation?
TS: It's kind of by a case-by-case basis, depending on who you're dealing with. Some people do want that report, especially if you have, with your homeowner's insurance— Some insurance companies now have insurance coverage for identity theft and fraud where you would need to provide that type of report. It's just good to have it. And it's sort of like, I would rather someone have it and not need it than need it and then be like, oh, geez, I need to call the police department. That should just be one of the first things you do just so you have that done.
KW: What are some of the bigger trends that you're seeing? We've talked about the cryptocurrency. Are there other trends that you're seeing in identity theft that we should know about?
TS: Probably the biggest trend that we're seeing here recently, and it's really gaining ground, is actually affecting more of our youth, minors. And there's different variations of this.
They can be people that are just trying to extort people for money online that might live in the United States or might live overseas, all the way up to, and there's these groups called Nihilistic Violent Extremists. And those are groups like 764, different groups that are certainly within the United States, but also around the world.
And what those groups are based on is finding people, finding kids that might be in—and I'll give an example of somebody that maybe is LGBTQ—and they might be in a chat room dealing with support issues with that. Those people will focus on those chat rooms to find potential victims. And there was a minor victim out of Gig Harbor, and I believe this was about two years ago, where he had met somebody online and then started getting extorted to a certain extent. And then the theme of these groups are to get as much out of people as possible.
In that instance with the Gig Harbor kid, he ended up live streaming on Instagram when he hung himself and his parents were asleep at the time. And then they were contacted the next morning and he had died. We've had instances here certainly locally of kids being extorted to make content that would be sexual in nature, to do things to maybe the family dog.
We had a case up in South Spokane where the family dog was mutilated because the kid was being extorted. Because the issue then becomes is kind of the same thing we were talking about earlier, where you'll have somebody, a kid will meet another person online. And my 16-year-old or 13-year-old victim here in Spokane thinks they're talking to a 13 or 16-year-old boy in maybe another state.
And so the conversation develops and they will go back and forth and it will be, hey, send me a picture of yourself. And it'll be, send me a picture of yourself, maybe undressed or doing other things. And so once that picture then gets into the suspect's hands, then that turns around and then they're getting text messages. They're getting emails. And it's basically the theme of those messages are you were going to do X, Y, or Z. Otherwise we're sending these pictures to your friends, to your family, to your classmates.
And the issue, I think what really scares me to a certain extent is that in these cases that I've seen so far, it is the minor victim that has come forward to their parents and the parents have called the police and I will go interview them. And that's great. And we can deal with that. And we can, a lot of those cases do go overseas. I do have cases here that are still within the United States where the suspect is at. The concern I have is the kids that are, for whatever reason, uncomfortable or scared or whatever it might be, they don't tell their parents or they don't have a trusted adult. And then they're just in this world and then they, they just get sucked into it because those are the cases I don't know about that we don't know about.
And I can't, I can't, I can't get to those people if I don't know them and try to help them out.
KW: That's frightening. So what, if you were speaking to a room full of junior high and high school kids, what's the advice that you would give them to keep themselves safe online?
TS: Absolutely. So, and I've started doing these presentations for both kids and for parents and for school administrators. And so in speaking with kids, it is just, you know, be careful with who you're talking to online. The kids now are very different than when I went to high school and junior high.
I mean, they live in a different world with technology and the phones and all the things. So it's just part of their world. The issue is, is I don't think they realize just like you wouldn't have your kid, your 13 year old walking out on, you know, East Sprague at two in the morning, you shouldn't have your kid have full access to the internet because there's so many different things out there that are predatory in nature where they could be victimized.
So what I tell kids is that be aware. If you meet somebody online, try to verify who they are. If you, you know, if you've developed a relationship online with somebody, that's great.
You can continue that communication. I'm not telling you not to do that. But what I am telling you is that there's no reason in the world why you would need to send pictures of yourself to another person.
Please don't do that. Even if it's a real boyfriend or girlfriend that you have, eventually they might break up and that image is still out there. So that has been the thing that I keep trying to emphasize to people.
And also with the kids, you know, so it's not that necessarily they could be the potential victim, but also to watch out for their friends and their younger siblings so they have more ownership in it as well. Be watchful for these things.
If you're hearing, you know, the word Snapchat and new boyfriend or new girlfriend in the same sentence, that should be sort of a red flag of, hey, let's follow up with this. Are the settings on the phone, do they have free access? Do they have chat capability on?
And again, some of these scams are on, some of these instances happen on things like Roblox or things that are, that certainly my kid used back when they were little. So these are, these are very common. So basically it's just awareness that these predators are out there.
Please don't give anybody anything that they might try to do something to you.
KW: And it sounds like it would behoove parents to really think through what they allow their kids to have access to online and knowing what they're accessing online.
TS: Yes. Having—making sure that it's not just, you know, handing the phone over to the kids so they have some peace and quiet. It is the, it's the conversation. It's, you know, what apps are on the phone, what apps are you using? And it can't, it doesn't have to be the grand inquisition.
It can be, hey, what fun games are you playing now? You know, Roblox or the other ones, Minecraft was the other big one. And just kind of know what's on those sites, look on those apps and see, you know, is there a chat feature on, on these platforms? Normally there are. Is anybody, is there a way to set it so they can only communicate with people that they know? Or can anyone friend them? How does that work? But just basically find out what your kids are on and how they're using it.
KW: As a parent too, having that conversation where you're asking those questions can be perceived as an interrogatory, even if you're not intending it to. Are there ways that you can couch it so that they know it's not that I don't trust you—I don't necessarily trust the people on the other end of the line that I don't know.
TS: Yeah. And that is, and it kind of depends on your own kid. I have one, one of my kids is very, he's very quiet. The other one likes to talk about everything.
So you have to kind of deal with it from two different angles, but it's basically, it's not an inquisition. It's more just asking, you know, what's fun online. What are you playing? What games are you playing? And invariably, at least in my experience, like if you ask a kid, "Hey, tell me about Minecraft." They will start talking, right.
And it's like, and in my case, with my started talking about Minecraft, I really had no idea what they were talking about, but at least they were talking. And so we kind of developed that line of communication and it'll be like, "Well, that's pretty cool. Are you able to meet other people there or how does that work?" And then you can just get more information just out of the pure conversation of I'm interested in what you're interested in. Tell me more about it.
KW: And fake it if you're not interested because it's your kid.
TS: A hundred percent. I couldn't tell you the first thing about Minecraft. Even when it was explained to me, I had no idea what it was like, what the purpose was, but boy, I can pretend that I'm super interested in it.
KW: Anything else that we can let parents and older adults know to keep them safe that we haven't covered yet?
TS: I think the overall thing that probably is the most important is just having community where you have your family and your friends and check in on people. Because again, a lot of these scams, especially dealing with the older adults, but also what we were just talking about with kids, they work best for the scammer when that person kind of gets in their own head.
I remember early on, I was dealing with a nice woman who was elderly and she was concerned that—I think it was the Sheriff's office. She'd gotten a call from the Sheriff's office. Actually, it was a text from the Sheriff's office that they were going to be conducting a warrant at her retirement village because she had an outstanding warrant and she was concerned that that was going to happen.
It sounds, certainly sitting in law enforcement, like that's never going to happen. But again, if you don't know, you can get scared. Just in that example, even if she had talked to her neighbors, that doesn't sound right, and they could say, "Well, you should probably call the local Sheriff's office and find out."
Same thing with the kids. It's like, as long as they're not trapped in their own head and they're panicking, things are okay. The problem is when people panic and things need to be done right now, there's a sense of urgency.
If you can take a breath, talk to someone you know. That usually can help mitigate or solve the problem entirely. Again, just like the other examples of, I don't think the IRS is going to have you pay your back taxes through these crypto ATM machines, that type of thing. That was sort of the point of trying to ban them, is if we can have somebody that's in Spokane that can't find one and someone wanting them to drive to Coeur d'Alene, they might stop and think, well, this seems odd that I would be driving all this way and maybe stop and ask that question.
It's not a perfect way to mitigate these issues, but it does mitigate them.
KW: One last question. How elaborate and believable has the spoofing become?
TS: Very believable. I'll give you an example. I don't have 2025 numbers, but in 2024, $6-billion went from the United States to China just in crypto scams. These are run by, in essence, the triads, the Chinese organized crime.
When you're making that much money, you can be putting money into your scams. I'll give the example of investment scams. Same process.
You'll meet somebody online, develop that relationship, and then that person will be like, hey, if you invested in Bitcoin or Ethereum, you can make a lot of money. What will happen is that person will say, send that to my victim and say, "This is the website I use. It's a great website, and you can put your money into here, and you're going to make a lot of money."
That website is obviously run entirely by the scamming operation. What happens is that person opens up an account just like you would anywhere else where you have all your information. They know your social security number, your date of birth, the answers on the test questions, all the things.
Then what has happened is people will put in maybe $500 or $1,000, and the big concern is, can I get my money back out? And again, the scammers are controlling the website, so they can turn that $500 to $1,000 into $5,000 fairly quickly, and everything's great. The concern then is, can I get my money out? The scammers know this, and so what will happen is they will let the people withdraw money back to their checking account or whatever account they linked to it, and that money goes back in, and it's like, well, that's great. I can get my money back out, and then it goes into overdrive, and so then you'll have people investing hundreds of thousands of dollars in this type of scam, and then it is, we got you.
Then either it is, I want my money back, or I need to start withdrawing more money, or something doesn't seem right here, and it will be like, oh, yes, you can, but there are certain taxes with this amount, so you'll need to pay another $50,000 because of your gains, pay that in taxes ahead of time, and so people are kind of hoping against hope, and so they pay another $50,000, and they never get their money back, so we've had a number of scams just like that.
KW: So how can we protect ourselves when it comes to phone calls and texts and emails to know what's real and what's not?
TS: So the thing I tell people is, if you don't have a contact in your phone number, and you just have this random number calling you, let it go to voicemail. If somebody needs you, they'll leave a voice message. If it's a text message, you don't know who the person is, don't respond to it.
KW: Are they elaborate enough to spoof company logos and things like that?
TS: They spoof company logos. They can spoof phone numbers, so you can theoretically be getting a phone call when it looks like from the Spokane Police Department saying, hey, you have a warrant and you need to pay this.
They've spoofed this, so it comes up on the caller ID, Spokane Police Department. Even in instances like that, always double check. "That sounds good, I'm going to let you go, but I'm going to call back and find out."
And they'll try to keep you on the line, of course, but then you can call back and be like, "No, that's a scam."
KW: And I would imagine if they're trying to keep you on the line, that should be a red flag, yes?
TS: Absolutely it is. Absolutely it is.
KW: Any additional takeaways you want to leave us with? Because you provided us with a lot of information, some of which I knew, a lot of which I didn't.
TS: It's basically just proceed with caution. I think the internet, and I think that this has been maybe good for society, but there's a lot out there, and I think there's a lot of good things on the internet where you can meet people, you can develop community, but you also have to be safe about that.
So if you don't know the person in real life, you've got to double check. And I'll say with that, this kind of all goes out the window too with the advancement of AI, because what will happen is, and I'll give the example of what's happening right now, your listeners are listening to me talk on the air. Someone could theoretically record our voices and then run it through AI, and then they can have us say whatever they want us to.
Where that has happened locally is you will have usually grandparents with a late teen, early twenties grandchild. And again, a lot of this information's online. People have opened Facebook pages so that a lot of that stuff gets researched.
And it will be, "Hey grandma, this is Bobby. I just got arrested. Please don't tell mom and dad. I need you to wire $15,000 to my attorney to get me out of whatever mess I'm in."
And they'll send that. And Bobby was never arrested.
And the person will swear, I know I was talking to Bobby. And it's like, you kind of were, because that was his voice run through artificial intelligence.
KW: Brave new world, and not in a good way.
TS: No, I'm super fun at parties.
KW: Detective Schwering, thank you so much for your time. This is invaluable information for all of our listeners and for myself too. Thank you.
TS: Thank you for having me. I appreciate it.
KW: That was Detective Tim Schwering with the Spokane Police Department's Criminal Intelligence Unit.