© 2026 Spokane Public Radio.
An NPR member station
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Nathan Weinbender reviews "The Only Living Pickpocket in New York"

John Turturro gives one of the best performances of his storied career in The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, which Nathan Weinbender says is a deliberately paced, gloomily funny portrait of a city in flux.

It’s hard out there for a pickpocket in 2026, when no one carries cash anymore and every square inch of the planet is covered by security cameras. Harry Lehman has been lifting wallets and wristwatches for years, though he’s still operating like it’s 1985. It’s what gets him caught.

He’s at the heart of The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, a movie that reads like a ticking-clock thriller but plays like an ambling character study. It’s also a snapshot of a city in flux, where the people who made the place what it is stand back, fade into the background and look on as it changes around them.

The movie stars John Turturro, who has been so good for so long, and he brings his usual easygoing, appealingly hangdog presence to it. His Harry Lehman is soft-spoken, mercurial, almost gentle. He’s either never lost his temper or repressed his violent streak a long time ago. Harry takes care of his catatonic wife and makes ends meet as a petty thief.

One night, he breaks into a car and walks off with a duffel bag that’s got a luxury watch, a gun and some kind of hard drive in it. The bag belongs to an aggro tech bro (Will Price) who has no trouble tracking Harry down, and he’s not happy that Harry has already pawned off that hard drive, which is actually the key to a crypto wallet containing nearly a million bucks. So Harry now has a do-or-die ultimatum: find the wallet or he and his loved ones get it.

Despite its premise, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York doesn’t have the jittery, sleep-deprived energy of the ’70s New York thrillers — like The French Connection or The Taking of Pelham One Two Three — it’s indebted to, or even a neo-noir panic attack like Uncut Gems, still the greatest 21st-century New York film. Writer-director Noah Segan, who’s best known as an actor, gives the movie a surprisingly easygoing, deliberate pace, which matches the tempo of Gary Lionelli’s jazzy score.

The film is as no-nonsense as Harry Lehman himself; it’s terse, it’s efficient, it doesn’t get bogged down in unnecessary detail. Harry is a man without an island, a mentor without a protege, and the movie takes its cues from his gloomily funny, bone-weary worldview.

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is less about one man’s desperate scramble than it is the specter of obsolescence: Segan’s New York is populated by old-timers overshadowed by new money, the character of a city eclipsed by gentrification and development. Even Harry’s go-tos are facing it, including Giancarlo Esposito as a veteran cop who’s about to be put out to pasture and Steve Buscemi as a pawn shop owner baffled by new technology.

The movie, refreshingly, doesn’t turn into a bromide about intergenerational rifts. It merely shows them. There are no more payphones from which to make untraceable calls, no manual cash registers to pilfer, no discrete dropoff locations that aren’t being surveilled. That’s just the way of the world.