The filmmaker James Gray knows New York. And he’s obsessed with characters who struggle. In the films Little Odessa, We Own the Night, The Immigrant, Armageddon Time and others, Gray has over the years told stories of people who battle just to obtain a mere measure of the good life that many of us take for granted. Maybe fewer of us than in the recent past thanks to various economic factors such as soaring gas prices, etc., but still …
Gray continues his trademark focus on theme and setting in Paper Tiger, a film set in 1986 New York that boasts an all-star cast: Adam Driver, Scarlett Johansson and Miles Teller.
Teller and Johansson play Irwin and Linda Pearl, a middle-class couple living in the borough of Queens who are raising their two boys, Scott (played by Gavin Goudey) and Ben (played by Roman Engel), with the hopes that they will – as a sign of the times – go to college and have successful lives.
Then one night Irwin’s brother Gary, played by Driver, enters the scene. While the brothers are affectionate, it’s clear they live distinctly separate lives. Irwin is an engineer who runs his own modest company, while Gary is a former NYPD police officer – and someone with influence based both on his police connections and his apparent post-career success as a security specialist.
Gary wants to use that influence to get into business with Irwin, which is the specter that fuels writer-director Gray’s plot. Because the people with whom Gary wants to do business are Russian emigres who have won a contract to clean up an area around the Brooklyn docks. And as we learn, these Russians don’t care too much, if at all, about environmental regulations.
Which is something that, after being hired to do consultation regarding the clean-up, the naïve Irwin quickly learns to his regret. Intent on showing his sons what he does for a living, he takes them on a night-time visit to the docks where he sees the Russians … well, doing something that would disappoint even the current version of the federal Environmental Protection Agency.
This sets in motion a series of events involving Irwin and the boys being threatened, Gary and Irwin trying to mollify the Russian boss – an internationally connected mobster named Bogoyavich (played by Victor Ptak) – without much success, then Bogoyavich actually demanding extortion money from the brothers … and so on, each step of Gray’s plot growing ever more twisted and threatening.
At the same time, Johansson’s Linda – besides being irate that Irwin has put what she refers to as “my beautiful boys” in harm’s way – is facing her own concerns following a serious health prognosis.
Throughout all this, Gray – even more so than in films past – keeps things moving smoothly. He manages to capture New York and the era in ways that feel authentic, from the typical Queens house in which the Pearl family lives to Irwin’s dorky glasses and Linda’s dated hairstyle. Even the revolver that Gary carries strapped to his ankle looks more like something out of old Law & Order episodes than the modern semiautomatic pistols of today.
Speaking of which, Driver’s Gary becomes the film’s center. His arrogance, his hubris – as the Greeks would say – mixed with his brother’s simple good intentions turns what might have been an otherwise ordinary story into something close to a modern tragedy.
And Driver plays him perfectly. Once a fixture on television, cast in the HBO series Girls, Driver has become an A-list movie actor, appearing in both serious dramas such as Marriage Story (for which he won a Best Actor Oscar nomination) and in a trio of Star Wars films.
Johansson (a two-time Oscar nominee herself) and Teller are his match, though she is better at pulling off a local accent – something that most non-New Yorkers aren’t apt to notice.
In the end, Gray’s title Paper Tiger refers to something that could stand as a symbol for all his work: In struggling to find your way in life, what price must you pay when you reach, ambitiously but vainly, beyond your grasp?